Xreferat.com » Топики по английскому языку » Should press de liable or not english

Should press de liable or not english

ideas that we presently enjoy.

       This analysis  suggests  that  the  workings of the market create

    situation in which consumers of political information  do  not  need

    the  threat  of  producer  liability  to  guarantee  that  they  are

    systematically getting a TRUSTWORTHY product.

       But consumers are not the only  potential  victims  of  defective

    information and market incentives are not always adequate to protect

    NONCONSUMER victims from the harm of defective information. Innocent

    bystanders,  such  as pedestrians hit by defective motorcycles,  are

    sometimes hurt by products over whose producers they have no control

    either as consumers or competitors. Persons, who find themselves the

    unwitting subjects of defective information,  stand in an  analogous

    position.

       For example,   a   story  about  sexual  assault  might  be  very

    interesting for public and might serve well the public  interest  in

    being  informed about the police efforts or criminal justice system.

    But the victim's name is  NOT  NECESSARY  to  its  purpose  and  its

    publication both invades her privacy and broke her safety.  In cases

    like this, it's not so easy to have confidence in market incentives.

    The  harm  from  the  defect  is  highly  concentrated on the single

    defamed or exposed individual.

       Now, it's time to ask the major question:  Should  the  press  be

    permitted  to  externalize particularized harms?  Why should not the

    press,  like other business entities,  be liable when defects in its

    products  cause  particularized harm to individual third parties who

    have few means of self-protection at their disposal?

       According to the Constitution,  defamed public officials or  rape

    victims  should  have  access  to  massmedia  for  rebuttal.  As for

    everyday practice,  the press is not always eager to give  space  to

    claims  that it has erred.  There are two objections,  why the press

    shouldn't be responsible for the harm of such  kind:  accountability

    to  a  more  demanding legal standard would compromise its financial

    viability and undermine its independence.

       These objections are too  SELF-SERVING  to  be  taken  completely

    seriously:  The  financial  viability argument is no more persuasive

    when the product of the press harms innocent third parties  than  it

    is   when   other   manufacturers'   malfunctioning   products  harm

    bystanders.  As  press  doesn't   underproduce   information,   thus

    "freedom" from liability can't be defended as necessary subsidy. The

    "financial viability" objection  points  toward  the  imposition  of

    liability for harm.

       The need  to  maintain  the  press's independence from government

    does provide  support  for  the  press's  objection  that  liability

    threatens  them  unduly.  But  it's  hard  to sustain the claim that

    government's censorious hand would lurk behind a rule that  required

    the  press  to  compensete  individuals.  It  is  not  obvious  that

    enforcing a rule that simply prohibited publishing the names of rape

    victims would signal the beginning of the end of our cherished press

    freedom.

       Asking whether the press should be more legally accountable  than

    it  is now for publishing defamatory falsehoods about individuals or

    revealing rape victims' names touches a number of difficult,  highly

    discussed questions. In spite of the fact, by recasting a portion of

    the debate over legal accountability and by  focusing  attention  on

    the   disparity   of   legal  treatment  between  producers  in  the

    information  market  and  those  in  other  markets  for  goods  and

    services,  it  does  seem  possible  to gain some fresh and possibly

    useful insight.

       The reality seems to be that,  with respect to  the  quality  and

    quantity   of   political   information,  free  competition  in  the

    marketplace of ideas performs  admirably,  with  inventive  ways  of

    overcoming  market  failure  and  with  flexibility in adapting to a

    countless consumers preferences.

       In light of this reality it ought not to be amiss to suggest that

    when neither the threat of increasing a supposed undersupply nor the

    looming shadow of government censorship is implicated, the massmedia

    should be liable for egregious errors.

                    

Если Вам нужна помощь с академической работой (курсовая, контрольная, диплом, реферат и т.д.), обратитесь к нашим специалистам. Более 90000 специалистов готовы Вам помочь.
Бесплатные корректировки и доработки. Бесплатная оценка стоимости работы.

Поможем написать работу на аналогичную тему

Получить выполненную работу или консультацию специалиста по вашему учебному проекту
Нужна помощь в написании работы?
Мы - биржа профессиональных авторов (преподавателей и доцентов вузов). Пишем статьи РИНЦ, ВАК, Scopus. Помогаем в публикации. Правки вносим бесплатно.

Похожие рефераты: