The profile of an effective manager
3. Can we learn how to become an effective manager?
Last decades, many visions thought that we could learn how to become an effective manager. We could refer to the success of many institutions where MBA programs are offered. Many young high intelligent business men are taught how to become successful. Nevertheless the success of these business schools, there is a lack of correlation between scholastic standing and the success in business. Clearly, what a student learns about management in graduate school, does not equip him to build a successful career in business.
For Livingstone S. (1971) the reason for this failure could be found in the fact that48:”they don’t learn from their formal education what they need to know to perform their job effectively. The tasks that are the most important in getting results usually are left to be learned on the job, where few managers ever master them simply because no one teaches them how.”
Formal management education programs typically emphasize the development of skills which enables the future manager to solve problems and to make decisions (‘respondent behaviour). But little attention is given to the development of skills required to find the problems that need to be solved (‘operant behaviour’). Furthermore, the problem solving in the classroom is seen as an entirely rational process, while in reality human emotions make it hard to deal with the problems objectively.
As the research of Norman H. Mackworth revealed49, the distinction between the problem-solver and the problem-finder s vital. He concluded that managers not only should be able to analyze data of financial statements or other written reports, but even more important they should be able to scan the business environment for less concrete clues that a problem exist. These perceptual skills are extremely difficult to develop in the classroom and must be developed on the job.
We should ask our self the question: Are there people who have more managerial skills than others, because they are able to learn from their experience what they need to know to manage effectively. Livingstone S (1971) found three characteristics of men who learned to manage effectively.
Need to manage: to be able to manage effectively, you should have a strong desire and satisfaction to influence the performance of others. Many of those who aspires high- level positions are driven by the expectations of high salaries or high status, but are not motivated to get effective results through others. Those managers don’t learn how to develop an effective managerial career, because there is a lack of willingness to manage. They are not able to devote enough time and energy to find a suitable way to manage. So the need to manage is a crucial factor in determining whether a person will learn and apply in practice what is necessary to get effective results on the job. For example, managers who are outstanding individual performers, but with a lack to motivate others or to delegate tasks to subordinates, rarely advance far up the organizational hierarchy because they will be blocked by low performances of a large number of subordinates.
Need for power: Since managers are primarily concerned with directing and influencing subordinates, they should be characterized by a high need for power. We could refer to the above chapter about leadership and power.
Capacity for empathy: The capacity for empathy is ”the ability to cope with the emotional reactions that inevitably occur when people work together in an organization” (Livingstone S. 1971). Managers who are perfectly capable to learn from their job experience, or who are able to apply management techniques successfully, often fail because their affinity with others is entirely intellectual or cognitive. They are emotionally blind. They are not capable to deal with the emotional reactions that are crucial in gaining the willing cooperation of subordinates. It is very difficult to teach people how to cope with human emotions.
So we could conclude that there should be a combination of inborn characteristics and acquired knowledge and experience to become an effective manager. There are people wit a higher needs for managing and power and having a bigger capacity for empathy than others. But these features are no guarantee for success. They should be combined with technical and conceptual skills acquired during management education and job experience.
But the effective manger is one, who is able to adapt his personality, skills, knowledge and relationships in such a way that it fits the demands of their specific situation.
Attachment 1 50
M![]()
![]()
![]()
essage
Medium
Receiver
Encoding Decoding
![]()
![]()
S![]()
![]()
![]()
ender
Noise
Message
![]()
![]()
Feedback
1. Message: a purpose to be conveyed
2. Encoding: converting a message into symbols
3. Channel: the medium a message travels along
4. Decoding: retranslating a sender’s message. Difficulties may occur here, especially in intercultural communication.
5. Feedback: returns the message to the sender and provides a check on whether understanding has been achieved.
Noise: any disturbance that interferes with the transmission, receipt or feedback of a message
Attachment 2 51
HIERARCHY OF CHANNEL RICHNESS
Channel Type of message Information medium
Richness
Richest Nonroutine, ambiguous
![]()
![]()
Face-to-face talk
Telephone
Electronic mail
Memos, letters
Flyers, bulletins, general reports
Leanest Routine, clear
1 Management, By: Robbins, S.P., 1991, , Prentice-Hall, Inc, p. 4.
2 Begrippen van Management, By: Jegers M., Moenaert R., Verbeke A., 1994, , VUB-press, p.17.
3 The nature of Managerial work By: Mintzberg H., 1973, , New York, Harper&Row, p. 93-94.
4 The General Managers, By: Kotter J.P.,1982, , New York Free Press.
5 Skills of an effective administrator, By: Katz R.L., 1974, , Harvard Business Reiew 52.
6 Management, By: Robbins, S.P., 1991, , Prentice-Hall, Inc, p. 4.
7 The General Managers, By: Kotter J.P.,1982, , New York Free Press, p. 36.
8 Organization Theory and Design, By Richard L. Daft, 2nd Edition,1983
9 Actionable learning, By Terrence Morrison, Asia Development Bank Institute
10 Human Problem Solving By: Herbert Simon and R. Newel,NY:NORTON,1990
11 Extract from” The Next big Idea” By Carol Kennedy, Random House Business Books, www.cec.globalcources
12 Essentials of Organizational Behavior. By, Robbins, Stephen P. New Jesrsey: Prentice Hall, 2002
13 Putting Spirituality to Work. By, Professor Kerns
14 Why Decisions Fail By: Paul C. Nutt, Berrett-Koehler Publishers, Inc., San Francisco, CA,2002
15 Grant, Quacy. Conflict and Conflict Management. Taking It Global -
takingitglobal/express/article.html?cid=1227
16 Grant, Quacy. Conflict and Conflict Management. Taking It Global -
takingitglobal/express/article.html?cid=1227
17 Cribbin, James J. Effective Managerial Leadership. American Management Association, Inc. USA: 1972
18 Cribbin, James J. Effective Managerial Leadership. American Management Association, Inc. USA: 1972
19 Robbins, Stephen P. Essentials of Organizational Behavior. New Jersey: Prentice Hall, 2002.
20 Kerns, Dr. Charles. “The Five A’s of Improving Your Personal Effectiveness”. Graziadio Business Report. September 2002.
21 Are you flexible enough to succeed? , By: Raudsepp, Eugene, Manage, Mar90, Vol. 41, Issue 4
22 Longman Dictionary of Contemporary English,pearson Education Limited,1978,2001
23 Are you flexible enough to succeed? , By: Raudsepp, Eugene, Manage, Mar90, Vol. 41, Issue 4
24 George T. Geis, research coordinator at UCLA's Center of Human Resource Management at Are you flexible enough to succeed? , By: Raudsepp, Eugene, Manage, Mar90, Vol. 41, Issue 4
25 The Unblocked Manager, By: Mike Woodcock,Dave Francis,England,GB,1983
26 Longman Dictionary of Contemporary English,pearson Education Limited,1978,2001
27 Becoming a Master Manager, By:Robert E.Qiunn,Sue R.Faerman,Michel P. Thomson, Michael R. McGrath; USA,2003
28 Becoming a Master Manager, By:Robert E.Qiunn,Sue R.Faerman,Michel P. Thomson, Michael R. McGrath; USA,2003
29 Becoming a Master Manager, By:Robert E.Qiunn,Sue R.Faerman,Michel P. Thomson, Michael R. McGrath; USA,2003
30 Mentors Are Guides to Success , By: Wilson, Cheryl F., Black Collegian, Apr2002, Vol. 32, Issue 3
31 Do your managers have the right stuff? , By: Simonsen, Piggy, Workforce, Aug99, Vol. 78, Issue 8
32 Do your managers have the right stuff? , By: Simonsen, Piggy, Workforce, Aug99, Vol. 78, Issue 8
33 Do your managers have the right stuff?, By: Simonsen, Piggy, Workforce, Aug99, Vol. 78, Issue 8
34 Ellen D. Rothberg, Greg Blencoe
35 Adaptive Skills , By: Yelverton, Jerry, Vital Speeches of the Day, 0042742X, 09/15/97, Vol. 63, Issue 23
36 Pankoff Sr., J. A
37 I will use this book as a lead to construct the rest of this section: Robbins, Stephen P. (2001). Organizational Behavior. New Jersey: Prentice Hall, pp. 154-216
38 This classification is subjective and doesn’t claim at all to be exhaustive.
39 A remarkable effort to explain these problems was provided by Hofstede, who placed cultures on a continuum of high-context vs. low-context cultures. In the former, the context is of extreme importance; what not is said may be more significant than what is said (for example Japan). In the latter, words are more important to transfer meaning than the context in which communication takes place (for example North America). It is then your task as a manager to take these in consideration.
40 Here I would like to refer to the interesting theories Deborah Tannen developed in the ‘90’s. One of her conclusions was that men use talk to emphasize status, whereas women use it to create connection. She even states that the two sexes belong to two different cultures and speak as such different genderlects (Tannen, 1991, p. 37). As such, intergender communication can be a barrier to effective communication. It is then your task as a manager to take these in consideration.
41 Szwajkowski, Eugene W. “The Myths and Realities of Research on Organizational
42 Robbins, Stephen P. Essentials of Organizational Behavior. New Jersey: Prentice Hall, 2002.
43 Robbins, Stephen P. Essentials of Organizational Behavior. New Jersey: Prentice Hall, 2002
44 Robbins, Stephen P. Essentials of Organizational Behavior. New Jersey: Prentice Hall, 2002
45 Kerns, Charles D. PhD, MBA. “Managerial Leadership at 12 o’clock.” Graziadio Business Report. Summer 2002.
46 Myth of the well-educated manager, By:Livingstone S;, 1971,, Harvard Business Review p.82.
47 Originality, By: Mackworth N.H., 1969, , in The Discovery of Talent p.242.
48 Myth of the well-educated manager, By:Livingstone S;, 1971,, Harvard Business Review p.82.
49 Originality, By: Mackworth N.H., 1969, , in The Discovery of Talent p.242.
50 Robbins, S. & Coulter, M. “Managerial Communication and information technology” p. 283
51 Robbins, Stephen P. (2001). Organizational Behavior. New Jersey: Prentice Hall, p. 295