Xreferat.com » Топики по английскому языку » The Role of Smallpox Vaccination in Mortality Decline in the Great Britain through Eradicating the Disease

The Role of Smallpox Vaccination in Mortality Decline in the Great Britain through Eradicating the Disease

book “Natural and Political Observations upon the Bills of Mortality”, and passing with the death of its key proponents, Gregory King in 1712 and Charles Davenant in 1714.  The term itself was devised by Sir William Petty in about 1671 or 1672.  The use of statistics in policy debate became more prevalent at around the same period.  It is up to one’s imagination to count the areas which were influenced by Political Arithmetick – social order, military matters, religious affiliation, economic performance, public finances, to name a few.  Furthermore, ‘Medical Arithmetick’ was being enthusiastically championed by 1780s, though its origins are rooted in much earlier periods.  As another author put it ‘Without medical arithmetic it is impossible to reach the “grandeur of generality”, the sublime of medical divination.’(Hoppit, 1996).

Almost a century after Adam Smith’s remark about unreliability of political arithmetick, a medical man, Dr. Guy, was presenting a paper on smallpox and vaccination at The Royal Statistical Society, and to the question whether vaccination were a preventive of smallpox, he answered that “there can be no answer except such as is couched in the language of figures” (Greenwood, 1930).  An amazing contrast in faith in numbers, isn’t it?  Where does it come from?  The thing is proponents of vaccination then and now had no other way of proving the efficacy of vaccines, smallpox vaccine in particular, than talking in the language of numbers.  Even though it may sound very odd, medicine had little role in proving efficacy of vaccines. The thing is vaccines are injected mostly to people in near-perfect health, and it would be very unethical to expose control groups to the dreadful diseases in order to prove the efficacy of vaccines.  The proponents of vaccination, people with strong ties in the governments and pharmaceutical-medical industry, have been trying to prove the efficacy of vaccines through statistical study of population mortality and morbidity, often making unbelievable claims.  Having reviewed dozens of historical materials about smallpox vaccination, I saw an obvious “play with numbers” in order to reach “politically correct” conclusions.  Medical historians McKeown and Record stated that 'the data (on mortality and natality) are so treacherous that they can be interpreted to fit any hypothesis' (Razzell, 1965).

Few tables below will illustrate this point:

Table 2.  Mean Annual Rate of Mortality per million from smallpox at all ages in three groups of years, selected with reference to optional  and obligatory vaccination (Milnes, 1897).

Dr. Ogle’s Division The Historical Division
Period Mortality Period Difference Mortality Period
1) Vaccination optional, 1847-53 305 82, or 26.8% 117, or 38.8% 305 1) Vaccination optional, 1847-53
2) Vaccination obligatory, but not efficiently enforced, 1854-71 223 109, or 48.8% 39, or 20.7% 188 2) Vaccination obligatory, but not efficiently enforced, 1854-67
3) Vaccination obligatory, but more efficiently enforced, 1872-87 114 149 3) Vaccination obligatory, but more efficiently enforced, 1868-87

Fascinatingly, all other infectious diseases, without any exception, decreased during this period, contributing to the falling mortality rates in Britain, a lot of them by larger percentage than smallpox.  Moreover, except smallpox, none of those infectious diseases were confronted by any inoculations and/or vaccines.  The below table will better illustrate the point:

Table 3.  Mortality compared, Smallpox with Fever Group (Typhus, Typhoid, and Simple and Ill-defined) for the Two periods, 1838-42 and 1871-75 (Milnes,1897).

Infectious Diseases 1838-42 1871-75 Decrease in %
Smallpox 576 414 26.4
Fever 1053 575 43.4

Table 4.  Mortality of Smallpox and Cholera compared, on Average per million, for the Twelve Years 1838-42 and 1847-53, and the Forty-two years 1854-1895 (Milnes, 1897).

Infectious Diseases 1838-42 & 1847-53 1854-95 Decrease in %
Smallpox 408 126 69
Cholera 320 69 78

Hence, with in regards to the above two tables, it becomes clear that there is no ground to attribute decline in smallpox mortality to smallpox vaccination, because if that were the case, smallpox must have declined by far larger percentage compared to other infectious diseases.  This is not a conclusion, which has been arrived at recently, on contrary this fact has been suppressed for political purposes, and has been known from the very beginning.

Late Dr. Gryzanovski noted the strange fascination in numbers: “Not only the mathematician, and the mystic philosopher, but the artists, the physicist, the economist, all feel it alike, and even those who are unable to comprehend the real nature of numbers, have an instinctive appreciation of their conclusiveness”.  Below is a good example how numbers can be misleading if used improperly.  During an agitation in favor of compulsory vaccination in Germany at the end of 19th century, the learned Professor Kussmaul went into great details by citing the occurrence of 3330 cases of smallpox in Marseilles in 1828.  According to the statistics that was presented by him to prove the necessity of mass vaccination, 2289 of the 3330 persons had not been vaccinated.  Out of these unvaccinated folks 420 or 18.3 per cent died, whereas the mortality among the vaccinated 1041 was only 17 or 1.7 per cent.  At first sight, it seems obvious that vaccinated folks were luckier and through saved lives smallpox vaccination caused an invaluable amount of economic gain, but that is only if we presume that data is correct and calculation is without any fault.  But now we have Dr. Lorinser’s data on Marseilles’ population in 1828, and proportion of vaccinated, 133000 and 33000 respectively.  And if now we recalculate using the correct denominators, we come up with a completely different picture.  In fact, it is the opposite of the initial finding that supported efficacy of the smallpox vaccination.  Mortality level among the vaccinated comes up to be 32 per thousand, while mortality level among the unvaccinated is 23 per thousand.  This recalculation of the data at hand not only disproves the initial claims of the efficacy of smallpox vaccination, but also shows that it was dangerous.  So who is right in this case?  Maybe both men’s conclusions were wrong, but Dr. Lorinser’s statistical methods seem to make more sense. (Gryzanovski, 1906). 

Hence, the role of smallpox vaccination in eradicating the disease in Britain seems to be exaggerated.  The first medical tool in preventing smallpox disease, inoculation, was pronounced illegal after being carried out on mass level for more than 120 years.  It is interesting to note that from the date of mandatory smallpox vaccination law in Britain in 1853 till the complete eradication of the disease in 1979, almost the same amount of time had passed as in the previous case.  One thing is different though – this time, with vaccination, medical men decided to end smallpox vaccination on a good note… After 1979, smallpox cases were spotted in a few LDCs (less developed countries) of the world, but the WHO did not re-initiate mass smallpox vaccination.

Conclusions and Directions for A Future Research

Without a doubt, eradication of smallpox disease was one of the greatest achievements of mankind.  It must be emphasized that this was the merit of combined forces of various factors, such as economic, sanitary, technological, and educational.  Arduous endeavors of certain groups to continue with inoculation long after it had been banned in 1840 were mentioned (NAVL, 1910), and this leads one to think that these groups probably had huge economic and/or political interests at stake. Estimation of economic benefits derived from smallpox immunization, both inoculation and vaccination, would shed light on the special interests behind this practice.  In case of inoculation that preceded vaccination, it seems to be a very low-cost (both start-up, and operations) and highly profitable field: all kinds of amateurs (from farmers to custom-officers) carried out inoculations throughout towns and villages, with little or no regulation; overseers of the poor paid for their parish to be inoculated.  For instance, the statement that “many gentlemen paid for inoculation of the children of the poor in their own neighborhoods” does signal huge economic spending on inoculation, but does in no way quantify the amount (Razzel, 1965).  The above description of smallpox inoculation resembles the current day Internet get-rich-instantly recipes, which also boast low-cost, huge potential markets, and little regulation. 

Vaccination replaced the arsenal of medical profession against the infectious diseases, but little has changed.  Many vaccine batches are found to be contaminated even during our days, and there is still no sure way to inspect their quality, few vaccine manufacturers work as a monopoly.  Vaccine manufacturers and doctors who carry out the vaccination practice are legally freed from liability on any consequent damage caused by vaccines (NVIC.COM).

I was not able to economically compare the weight of smallpox vaccination compared to other forces, mainly not due to the lack of data on smallpox mortality or economic and other developments in Britain between 18th and 20th centuries, but due to impossibility to measure things with he same units.  How would you compare sanitation, increased knowledge of safe food preparation, better economic standards of living, higher levels of vaccination, and lower mortality rates?  How much is the worth of one human being’s life?  If just one child died after vaccination, and it turns out he was a potential new Einstein, how does that change economic calculations of losses due to post-vaccine mortality?  I tried to avoid going deep into analyzing mortality rates alone, because it would become a simple body count, not economics.  However, with little surprise, I discovered that among all the forces that are believed to have played role in eradicating smallpox, smallpox vaccination remains to be the most controversial to the date.

Список литературы

1.  Helleiner, Karl. “The Vital Revolution Reconsidered”.  The Canadian Journal of Economics and Political Science, Vol. 23, No. 1. February 1957.

2. M. Greenwood. “The Vaccination Problem”.  Journal of the Royal Statistical Society, Vol.93, No.2. 1930.

3.  Scott, Susan.  “The Dynamics of Smallpox Epidemics in Britain, 1550-1800”. Demography, Vol. 30, No. 3, August 1993.

4.  Milnes, Alfred.  “Statistics of Smallpox and Vaccination, with Special Reference to Age-incidence, Sex-incidence, and Sanitation”.  Journal of the Royal Statistical Society, Vol. 60, No. 3. September, 1897.

5.  Gryzanovski, Ernest.  “On Collective Phenomena and the Scientific Value of Statistical Data”.  Publications of the American Economic Association, 3rd Series, Vol. 7, No. 3.  August 1906.

6.  Encyclopedia Britannica online. britannica/

7.  Krause, J. T. “Changes in English Fertility and Mortality, 1781-1850”.  The Economic History Review, Vol. 11, No. 1. (1958).

8.  The National Anti-Vaccination League. (NAVL) “For and Against Vaccination”.  London, 1910.

9.  National Vaccine Information Centre. NVIC.COM

10.  World Health Organization: Smallpox Vaccination. WHO.ORG

Если Вам нужна помощь с академической работой (курсовая, контрольная, диплом, реферат и т.д.), обратитесь к нашим специалистам. Более 90000 специалистов готовы Вам помочь.
Бесплатные корректировки и доработки. Бесплатная оценка стоимости работы.

Поможем написать работу на аналогичную тему

Получить выполненную работу или консультацию специалиста по вашему учебному проекту
Нужна помощь в написании работы?
Мы - биржа профессиональных авторов (преподавателей и доцентов вузов). Пишем статьи РИНЦ, ВАК, Scopus. Помогаем в публикации. Правки вносим бесплатно.

Похожие рефераты: