Multiple Intelligences in the structure of a new English syllabus for secondary school
intelligences are used concurrently and typically complement each other as individuals develop skills or solve problems. For example, a dancer can excel in his art only if he has
1) strong musical intelligence to understand the rhythm and
variations of the music,
2) interpersonal intelligence to understand how he can inspire or emotionally move his audience through his movements, as well as
3) bodily-kinesthetic intelligence to provide him with the agility and coordination to complete the movements successfully.
Basis
for Intelligence
Gardner argues that there is both a biological and cultural basis for the multiple intelligences. Neurobiological research indicates that learning is an outcome of the modifications in the synaptic connections between cells. Primary elements of different types of learning are found in particular areas of the brain where corresponding transformations have occurred. Thus, various types of learning results in synaptic connections in different areas of the brain. For example, injury to the Broca's area of the brain will result in the loss of one's ability to verbally
communicate using proper syntax. Nevertheless,this injury will not remove the patient's understanding of correct grammar and word usage.
In addition to biology, Gardner (1983) argues that culture also plays a large role in the development of the intelligences. All societies value different types of intelligences.
The cultural value placed upon the ability to perform certain tasks provides the motivation to become skilled in those areas. Thus, while particular intelligences might be highly evolved in many people of one culture, those same intelligences might not be as developed in the individuals of another.
2.2. Psychological analysis of Gardner’s Theory
Despite swings of the pendulum between theoretical and applied concerns, the concept of intelligence has remained central to the field of psychology. In the wake of the Darwinian revolution, when scientific psychology was just beginning, many scholars became interested in the development of intelligence across species. The late 19th and early 20th centuries were punctuated by volumes that delineated levels of
intelligence across species and within the human species . Francis Galton (cousin of Charles Darwin) was perhaps the first psychologically oriented scientist to try to measure the intellect directly. Though
Galton
(1870) had a theoretical interest in the concept of intelligence, his
work was by no means unrelated to practical issues. A committed
eugenicist, he sought to measure intelligence and hoped, through
proper "breeding," to increase the overall intelligence of
the population.
During the following half century, many of
the most gifted and influential
psychologists concerned themselves with the nature of human intelligence. Although a few investigators were interested principally in theoretical issues, most seasoned their concerns with a practical orientation. Thus, Binet and Terman developed the first general-purpose intelligence tests in their respective countries; Yerkes and Wechsler created their own influential instruments. Even scientists with a strong
theoretical bent, like Spearman and Thurstone , contributed either
directly
or indirectly to the devising of certain measurement techniques and
the favoring of particular lines of interpretation.
By
midcentury, theories of intelligence had become a staple of
psychology textbooks, even as intelligence tests were taken for
granted in many industrialized countries.
Still,
it is fair to say that, within scientific psychology, interest in
issues of intelligence waned to some extent. Although
psychometricians continued to perfect the instruments that purported
to measure human intellect and some new tests were introduced , for
the most part, the burgeoning interest in cognitive matters bypassed
the area of intelligence.
This divorce between mainstream
research psychology and the "applied area" of intelligence
might have continued indefinitely, but by the late 70s, there were
signs of a reawakening of interest in theoretical and research
aspects of intelligence. With his focus on the information-processing
aspects of items in psychological tests, Robert
Sternberg was perhaps the most important catalyst for this shift,
but
researchers from a number of different areas of psychology have
joined in this rediscovery of the centrality of intelligence .
The
Theory of Multiple Intelligences
A
decade ago, Gardner found that his own research interests were
leading him to a heightened concern with issues of human
intelligence. This concern grew out of two disparate factors, one
primarily theoretical, the other largely practical.
As a
result of his own studies of the development and breakdown of
cognitive and symbol-using capacities, Gardner became convinced that
the Piagetian view of intellect was flawed. Whereas Piaget had
conceptualized all aspects of symbol use as part of a single "semiotic function,"
empirical evidence was accruing that the human mind may be quite modular in design. That is, separate psychological processes appear to be involved in dealing with linguistic, numerical, pictorial, gestural, and other kinds of symbolic systems .
Individuals may be precocious with one form of symbol
use, without any necessary carryover to other forms. By the same
token, one form of symbol use may become seriously compromised under
conditions of brain damage, without correlative depreciation of other
symbolic capacities . Indeed, different forms of symbol use appear to
be subserved by different portions of the cerebral cortex.
On
a more practical level, Gardner was disturbed by the nearly exclusive
stress in school on two forms of symbol use: linguistic symbolization
and logical-mathematical symbolization. Although these two forms are
obviously important in a scholastic setting, other varieties of
symbol use also figure prominently in human cognitive activity within
and especially outside of school. Moreover, the emphasis on
linguistic and logical capacities was overwhelming in the
construction of items on intelligence,
aptitude,
and achievement tests. If different kinds of items were used, or
different kinds of assessment instruments devised, a quite different
view of the human intellect might issue forth.
These and
other factors led Gardner to a conceptualization of human intellect
that was more capacious. This took into account a wide variety of
human cognitive capacities, entailed many kinds of symbol systems,
and incorporated as well the skills valued in a variety of cultural
and historical settings. Realizing that he was stretching the word
intelligence
beyond its customary application in educational psychology, Gardner
proposed the existence of a number of relatively autonomous human
intelligences. He
defined intelligence as the capacity to solve problems or to fashion
products that are valued in one or more cultural settings, and
detailed a set of criteria for what counts as a human intelligence.
Gardner's definition and his criteria deviated
significantly from established practices in the field of intelligence
. Most definitions of intelligence focus on the capacities that are
important for success in school.
Problem solving is recognized as a crucial component, but the ability to
fashion a productto write a symphony, execute a painting, stage a play, build up and manage an organization, carry out an experimentis not included, presumably because the aforementioned capacities cannot be probed adequately in short-answer tests.
Moreover,
on the canonical account, intelligence is presumed to be a universal,
probably innate, capacity, and so the diverse kinds of roles valued
in different cultures are not considered germane to a study of "raw
intellect."
For the most part, definitions and tests of intelligence are empirically determined.
Investigators search for items that predict who will succeed in school, even as they drop items that fail to predict scholastic success. New tests are determined in part by the degree of correlation with older, already accepted instruments. In sharp contrast, existing psychometric instruments play no role in Gardner's formulation. Rather, a
candidate
ability emerges as an intelligence to the extent that it has recurred
as an identifiable entity in a number of different lines of study of
human cognition.
To arrive at his list of intelligences,
Gardner and his colleagues examined the literature in several areas:
the development of cognitive capacities in normal individuals; the
breakdown of cognitive capacities under various kinds of organic
pathology; the existence of abilities in "special populations,"
such as prodigies, autistic individuals, idiots savants, and
learning-disabled children; forms of intellect that exist in
different species; forms of intellect valued in different cultures;
the
evolution of cognition across the millennia; and two forms of psychological evidencethe results of factor-analytic studies of human cognitive capacities and the outcome of studies of transfer and generalization. Candidate capacities that turned up repeatedly in these disparate literatures made up a provisional list of human
intelligences,
whereas abilities that appeared only once or twice or were
reconfigured differently in diverse sources were abandoned from
consideration.
The methods and the results of this massive survey are reported in detail in Frames of Mind and summarized in several other publications. Gardner's provisional list includes seven intelligences, each with its own component processes and subtypes (see supplement 3). It is
claimed that, as a species, human beings have evolved over the millennia to carry out at least these seven forms of thinking. In a biological metaphor, these may be thought of as different
mental "organs" ; in a computational metaphor, these
may be construed as separate information-processing devices . Although
all humans exhibit the range of intelligences, individuals differ--presumably for both hereditary and environmental reasons--in their current profile of intelligences.
Moreover,
there is no necessary correlation between any two intelligences, and
they may indeed entail quite distinct forms of perception, memory,
and other psychological processes.
Although few occupations
rely entirely on a single intelligence, different roles typify the
"end states" of each intelligence. For example, the
"linguistic" sensitivity to the sounds and construction of
language is exemplified by the poet, whereas the interpersonal
ability to discern and respond to the moods and motivations of other
people is represented in the therapist. Other occupations more
clearly illustrate the
need
for a blend of intelligences. For instance, surgeons require both the
acuity of spatial intelligence to guide the scalpel and the dexterity
of the bodily/kinesthetic intelligence to handle it. Similarly,
scientists often have to depend on their linguistic intelligence to
describe and explain the discoveries made using their
logical-mathematic intelligence, and they must employ interpersonal
intelligence in interacting with colleagues and in maintaining a
productive and smoothly functioning laboratory.
The
Education and Assessment
of Intelligences
Until this point, we have been reviewing the history of
intelligence research,
admittedly from the perspective of the Theory of Multiple Intelligences (hereafter MI
Theory). Since the publication of Frames of Mind , they and their
colleagues have been involved in investigating its implications. On the one hand, we seek to determine the scientific adequacy of the theory . On the other hand, in their view, a principal value of the multiple intelligence perspectivebe it a theory or a "mere" frameworklies in its potential
contributions to educational reform. In both cases, progress seems to revolve around assessment.
To demonstrate that the intelligences are relatively independent of
one
another and that individuals have distinct profiles of intelligences,
assessments of each intelligence have to be developed. To take
advantage of students' multiple intelligences, there must be some way
to identify their strengths and weaknesses reliably.
Yet
MI Theory grows out of a conviction that standardized tests, with
their almost xclusive stress on linguistic and logical skills, are
limited. As a result, the further development of MI Theory requires a
fresh approach to assessment, an approach consistent with the view
that there are a number of intelligences that are developedand can
best be detectedin culturally meaningful activities . In the
remainder of the paper, the scholars describe their approach to
assessment and broadly survey
their
efforts to assess individual intelligences at different age levels.
In addition, they report some preliminary findings from one of their
projects and their implications for the confirmation (or
disconfirmation) of MI Theory.
If, as argued, each
intelligence displays a characteristic set of psychological
processes, it is important that these processes be assessed in an
"intelligence-fair" manner. In contrast to traditional
paper-and-pencil tests, with their inherent bias toward linguistic
and logical skills, intelligence-fair measures seek to respect the
different modes of
thinking and performance that distinguish each intelligence. Although spatial problems can be approached to some degree through linguistic media (like verbal directions or word problems), intelligence-fair methods place a premium on the abilities to perceive and manipulate visual-spatial information in a direct manner. For example, the spatial intelligence of children can be assessed through a mechanical
activity in which they are asked to take apart and reassemble a meat grinder. The activity requires them to "puzzle out" the structure of the object and then to discern or remember the spatial information that will allow reassembly of the pieces. Although linguistically inclined children may produce a running report about the actions they
are
taking, little verbal skill is necessary (or helpful) for successful
performance on such a task.
Whereas most standard approaches
treat intelligence in isolation from the activities of a particular
culture, MI theory takes a sharply contrasting tack. Intelligences
are always conceptualized and assessed in terms of their cultural
manifestation in specific domains of endeavor and with reference to
particular adult "end states." Thus, even at
the preschool level, language capacity is not assessed in terms of vocabulary, definitions, or similarities, but rather as manifest in story telling (the novelist) and reporting (the journalist). Instead of attempting to assess spatial skills in isolation, we observe children as they are drawing (the artist) or taking apart and putting together
objects
(the mechanic).
Ideally, one might wish.to assess an
intelligence in a culture-independent way, but