Multiple Intelligences in the structure of a new English syllabus for secondary school
dependent on a person's familiarity and experience with the materials and demands of the assessments. In our own work, it rapidly became clear that meaningful assessment of an intelligence was not possible if students
had little or no experience with a particular subject matter or type of material. For example, our examination of bodily-kinesthetic abilities in a movement assessment for preschoolers was confounded by the fact that some four-year-olds had already been to ballet classes, whereas others had never been asked to move their bodies
expressively
or in rhythm. This recognition reinforced the notion that
bodily-kinesthetic intelligence cannot be assessed outside of a
specific medium or without reference to a history of prior
experiences.
Together, these demands for assessments that
are intelligence fair, are based on culturally valued activities, and
take place within a familiar context naturally lead to an approach
that blurs the distinctions between curriculum and assessment.
Drawing information from the regular curriculum ensures that the
activities are familiar;
introducing
activities in a wide range of areas makes it possible to challenge
and examine each intelligence in an appropriate manner. Tying the
activities to inviting pursuits enables students to discover and
develop abilities that in turn increase their chances of experiencing
a sense of engagement and of achieving some success in their society.
Putting Theory into Practice
In the past five years, this approach to assessment has
been explored in projects at several different levels of schooling.
At the junior and senior high school level, Arts PROPEL, a
collaborative project with the Educational Testing Service and the
Pittsburgh Public School System, seeks to assess growth and learning
in areas like music, imaginative writing, and visual arts, which are
neglected by most standard
measures .Arts PROPEL has developed a series of modules, or "domain
projects," that serve the goals of both curriculum and assessment. These projects feature sets of exercises and curriculum activities organized around a concept central to a specific artistic domainsuch as notation in music, character and dialogue in play writing, and graphic composition in the visual arts. The drafts, sketches, and final products generated by these and other curriculum activities are collected in portfolios
(sometimes
termed "process-folios"), which serve as a basis for
assessment of growth by both the teacher and the student. Although
the emphasis thus far has fallen on local classroom assessments,
efforts are also under way to develop criteria whereby student
accomplishment can be evaluated by external examiners.
At
the elementary level, Patricia Bolanos and her colleagues have used
MI theory to design an entire public school in downtown Indianapolis
. Through a variety of special classes (e.g., computing,
bodily/kinesthetic activities) and enrichment activities (a "flow"
center and apprentice-like "pods"), all children in the Key
School are given the opportunity to discover their areas of strength
and to develop the full range of intelligences. In addition, over the
course of a year, each
child executes a number of projects based on schoolwide themes, such as "Man and His Environment" or "Changes in Time and Space." These projects are presented and videotaped for subsequent study and analysis. A team of researchers from Harvard Project Zero is now engaged in developing a set of criteria whereby these videotaped projects can be assessed. Among the dimensions under consideration are project
conceptualization,
effectiveness of presentation, technical quality of project, and
originality, as well as evidence for cooperative efforts and
distinctive individual features.
A third effort, Project
Spectrum, co-directed by David Feldman of Tufts University, has
developed a number of curriculum activities and assessment options
suited to the "child-centered" structure of many preschools
and kindergartens .
At present, there are fifteen different activities, each of which taps a
particular intelligence or set of intelligences. Throughout the year, a Spectrum classroom is equipped with "intelligence-fair" materials. Miniature replicas and props invite children to deploy linguistic intelligence within the context of story telling; household objects that children can take apart and reassemble challenge children's
spatial intelligence in a mechanical task; a "discovery" area including natural objects like rocks, bones, and shells enables children to use their logical abilities to conduct small "experiments," comparisons, and classifications; and group activities such as a biweekly creative movement session can be employed to give children the
opportunity
to exercise their bodily-kinesthetic intelligence on a regular basis.
Provision of this variety of "high-affordance"
materials allows children to gain experiences that engage their
several intelligences, even as teachers have the chance unobtrusively
to observe and assess children's strengths, interests, and
proclivities.
More formal assessment of intelligences is also possible. Researchers can administer specific games to children and apply detailed scoring systems that have been developed for research purposes. For instance, in the bus game, children's ability to organize numerical information is scored by noting the extent to which they can keep track of the number of adults and children getting on and off a bus. Adults and children and on and off constitute two different dimensions. Thus, a child can receive
one of the following scores:
One dimensions recorded;
1.disorganized recording of one dimension (either adults and children or on and off);
2.labeled, accurate recording of one dimension;
3.disorganized recording of two dimensions;
4.disorganized
recording of one dimension and labeled, accurate recording of one
dimension; or 5labeled, accurate recording of two dimensions .
They have also created a related instrument, the Modified Spectrum
Field Inventory, that samples several intelligences in the course of
two one-hour sessions. Although this inventory does not draw directly
from the curriculum, it is based on the kinds of materials and
activities that are common in many preschools. In addition, related
materials
from the Spectrum curriculum can be implemented in the classroom to
ensure that the children will be familiar with the kinds of tasks and
materials used in the inventory.
Preliminary
Results from
Project Spectrum
Although none of these programs is in final form, and thus
any evaluation must be considered preliminary and tentative, the
results so far at the pilot sites seem promising. The value of rich
and evocative materials has been amply documented. In the classrooms
in Pittsburgh, Indianapolis, and Boston, teachers report heightened
motivation on the part of the students, even as students themselves
appreciate the opportunity to reflect on their own growth and
development. Moreover, our programs with both older and younger
children confirm that a consideration of a broader range
of
talents brings to the fore individuals who previously had been
considered unexceptional or even at risk for school failure.
As
for the assessment instruments under development, only those of
Project Spectrum have been field tested in classrooms. In 1987-89,
they used these instruments in two different settings to investigate
the hypothesis that the intelligences are largely independent of one
another. To examine this hypothesis, we sought to determine (a)
whether young children exhibit distinct profiles of intellectual strengths and weaknesses, and (b) whether or not performances on activities designed to tap different intelligences are significantly correlated. In the 1987-88 academic year, twenty children from a primarily white, upper-middle-income population took part in a year-long Spectrum program. In the 1988-89 academic year, the Modified Spectrum
Field
Inventory was piloted with fifteen children in a combined
kindergarten and first-grade classroom. This classroom was in a
public school in a low- to middle-income school district.
In the preschool study, children were assessed on ten different
activities (story telling, drawing, singing, music perception,
creative movement, social analysis, hypothesis testing, assembly,
calculation and counting, and number and notational logic) as well as
the Stanford-Binet Intelligence Scale, Fourth Edition. To compare
children's
performances across each of the activities, standard deviations were calculated for each activity. Children who scored one or more standard deviations above the mean were judged to have a strength on that activity; those who scored one or more standard deviations below the mean were considered to have a weakness on that activity. This analysis revealed that these children did not perform at the same level across activities and suggested that they do have distinct intellectual profiles. Of the
twenty children, fifteen demonstrated a strength on at least one activity, and twelve
children
showed a weakness on one or more activities. In contrast, only one
child was identified as having no strengths or weaknesses, and her
scores ranged from -.98 to +.87 standard deviations from the mean.
These results were reinforced by the fact that, for the most
part, children's
performances on the activities were independent. Using Spearman rank-order correlations, only the number activities, both requiring logical-mathematical intelligence, proved significantly correlated with one another (r = .78, p < .01). In the other areas, music and science, where there were two assessments, there were no
significant
correlations. Conceivably, this result can be attributed to the fact
that the number activities, both of which involved calculation,
shared more features than the music activities (singing and music
perception) or the science activities (hypothesis testing and
mechanical skill). Of course, the small sample size also may have
contributed to the absence of powerful correlations among measures.
A comparison of the Spectrum and Stanford-Binet assessments
revealed a limited relationship between children's performances on
these different instruments.
Spearman rank-order correlations showed that only performances on the number activities were significantly correlated with IQ (dinosaur game, r = .69, p < .003; bus game, r = .51, p < .04). With its concentration on logical-mathematic and linguistic skills, one might have expected a significant correlation with the Spectrum language activity as well. Conceivably, there was no significant correlation because the
Stanford-Binet
measures children's vocabulary and comprehension, whereas Spectrum
measures how children use language within a story-telling task.
In
the second study, eight kindergartners (four boys and four girls) and
seven first graders (five girls and two boys) were assessed on the
seven activities of the Modified Spectrum Field Inventory (MSPFI).
This inventory, based on the activities developed for the year-long
Spectrum assessments of preschoolers, consists of activities in the
areas of language (storyboard), numbers and logic (bus game), mechanics (assembly), art (drawing), music (xylophone games), social analysis (classroom model), and movement (creative movement). These assessments were administered in two one-hour sessions. Each activity was videotaped and children were scored by two
independent observers. Spearman rank-order correlations between the scores of the
two
observers ranged from .88 (language) to .97 (art) and demonstrated
the interrater reliability of these scores.
As in the first
study, strengths and weaknesses were estimated using standard
deviations. Unlike the findings from the earlier study, however,
these results revealed that some children performed quite well and
others performed quite poorly across many of the activities. It
appears that the small sample size and wide age ranges may have
contributed to this result. Of the five first-grade girls, none
demonstrated a weakness in any area; all showed at least one
strength, with one girl having strengths
in six of the seven areas. The two first-grade boys showed no strengths, and both demonstrated weaknesses in three areas. Of the kindergartners, only two showed any strengths, with all but one of the other children showing at least one weakness. Quite possibly, these results reflect differences in developmental level, and perhaps gender
differences
as well, that did not obtain in the preschool sample and that may
have overpowered certain individual differences. It is also
conceivable that a more extended exposure to, and greater familiarity
with, the Spectrum materials and activities, as in the year-long
Spectrum program, may have made the individual differences among
younger children more visible.
Nonetheless, an examination of
children's ranks on each of the activities revealed a more complex
picture. Although the first-grade girls dominated the rankings, all
but two children in the sample were ranked among the top five on at
least one occasion.
All
but one child also scored in the bottom five on at least one
activity. Considered in this way, children did exhibit relative
strengths and weaknesses across the seven activities.
To
determine whether or not performance on one activity was independent
of performance on the other activities, we standardized each of the
scores with a mean = O and standard deviation = 1 and performed
Spearman rank-order correlations. Because of the superior performance
of the first-grade girls, the performances of kindergartners and
first graders were computed separately.
Consideration of the kindergartners alone revealed only one correlation, between art and social analysis, that approached significance (r = .66, p < .071). For the sample of first graders, including the "high"-scoring girls, there were a number of significant correlations: language and assembly (r = .77, p < .04), language and numbers (r = .81,
p
< .027), movement and social analysis (r
= .77, p
< .04), and assembly and numbers (r
= .79, p
< .034).
With the exception of the performance of the
first graders in the second study, these results are reasonably
consistent with the claims of Ml Theory. For younger children,
performances on the Spectrum activities were largely independent,
relative strengths and weaknesses were uncovered, and there was a
significant correlation between
preschoolers' performances on the Spectrum activities and the Stanford-Binet in one of the two areas